|
|  1. Fourteen Stories Down |
 Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Bob Barna | .... Detective Baxter |
| Richard Baxter | .... Police Officer |
| Anthony Patrick Capuano | .... James Glass |
| Darren W. Conrad | .... Crime Scene Witness |
| Jason Coviello | .... Detective Joe Schillaci |
| Andrew D. Erath | .... Detective |
| Tamilee Espinosa | .... Crime Scene Witness |
| Wil Gonzalez | .... Mr. Hoyos |
| Lena Marie | .... Annette Shapiro |
| Noel Mirabal | .... Detective Rodriguez |
| Vin Morreale Jr. | .... Coroner |
| Angela Perkins | .... Detective |
| Joseph Setticase | .... Abe Metz |
| Elle Sunkara | .... Amy Hoyos |
| 2. "Murder, Murder, Murder" |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Alicia Alvis | .... Olivia's Mom |
| Linda Bochenek | .... Resident |
| Andrew D. Erath | .... Medical Examiner |
| Bryan Terry Snell | .... Nate Daniels |
| 3. Hazard Lights |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Jessie Bell | .... CSI |
| Robert Cushing | .... Self - Capt., Vermont State Police |
| Darius L. Francis | .... Bruce Roberts |
| Emma Kaplan | .... Self - Melissa Jenkins Student |
| Jack Malykin | .... Lt. Robert Cushing |
| Jackie Marsden | .... Patricia |
| Hannah McDonald | .... Self - Reporter, WPTZ News |
| Matthew Nally | .... Self - Detective, Sgt. |
| McRae Patterson | .... Tim |
 Nick Schroeder | .... Ronald |
| J. P. Sinclair | .... Self - Search Team Commander (ret.) |
| Rachael Swartz | .... Major Ingrid Jonas |
| Ryan Uptgraft | .... Detective Nally |
| 4. From the Deep |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Destinee Andrews | .... Self - Kimberly Holton's Best Friend |
| Brett Blaylock | .... Jacob Jones |
| Jeff Brown | .... Self - Reporter, Dover Post (ret.) |
| Steven Brown | .... Self - Lt., New Jersey State Police |
| Tamara Crane | .... Janice |
| Gisele Frame | .... Jacob's Mother |
| Ryan MacKenzie | .... Kimberly Holton |
| Lizz Matthews | .... Heather |
| Heather Nasakaitis | .... Self - Kimberly Holton's Forster Sister |
| Jon W. Perkins | .... R Michaels |
| Billy Porter | .... Self - Det., Delaware State Police (ret.) |
| Patrick Taft | .... Michael |
| Jim Thistle | .... Self - CSI, New Jersey State Police (ret.) |
| Debbie J Wright | .... Laura |
| 5. Tale of Two Knives |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Adam Brudnicki | .... Det. Don Martín |
| Bryan Buckley | .... Self - Asst. District Attorney |
| Derek Carver | .... Commander Brian Meyers |
| Frank Dillard | .... Self - Det., Ridgeland MS Police Department (ret.) |
| Cassandra Dotson | .... Self - Det., Ridgeland MS Police Department (ret.) |
| Harlen Ernest | .... Detective Dillard |
| Anishka J. Farrington | .... Assault Victim |
| Sabine Gousse | .... Carmen Sanders |
| Jay Heselschwerdt | .... Nosey Neighbor |
| Jill Holder | .... Nosey Neighbor |
| Emmanuel J. Jones | .... Larry |
| Kelly Ladd | .... Medical Examiner |
| Lanaya Lewis | .... Self - News Anchor, WJTV |
| Brian Myers | .... Self - Commander, Criminal Investigations Division Ridgeland |
| Devon Renell | .... Robert Harvey |
| Bisola Salimonu | .... Strangulation Victim |
| Yushica Wallace | .... Det. Cassandra Dotson |
| 6. Goodbye Horses |
| Robert Berlin | .... Detective Danny Plott |
| Angela Borrello | .... Bar Patron |
| Peter Buitenhek | .... Medical Examiner |
| Monty Crosby | .... Medical Examiner |
| Bing Fu | .... Special Agent Guillermo Auyon |
| Shawn Hatfield | .... U.S. Marshal |
| Kimberly Holmes | .... Self - News Reporter, WBOC |
| Carey Jones | .... Tina's Dad |
| Christopher Judd | .... Medical Examiner |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Janna Koffman | .... Tessa Van Hart |
| Kris Kozlowski | .... Detective Jim Huddle |
| Richard Lamparter | .... Restaurant patron |
| Corra Liddle | .... Self - Tess Van Hart's Daughter |
| Josiah Paul | .... Matthew Birch |
| Danny Plott | .... Self - Special Agent, Virginia State Police |
| Rose Shea | .... Self - Tessa Van Hart's Mother-In-Law |
| Fidelus Singleton | .... Jay Fowler |
| Justin Sterner | .... Brian Lee Cherrix |
| Meredith Sugarman | .... Pizza Girl #2 |
| Brett Taylor | .... Nosey Neighbor #3 |
| Eeyana Torres | .... Female Pizza Shop Employee |
| Walter Van Hart | .... Self - Tessa's Husband |
| 7. A Face With No Name |
| Thomas Dailey | .... Self - Sgt., Hope Mills NC Police Department |
| Amanda Daniel | .... Self -Andrew Derenzy's Sister |
| Nate Daniel | .... Self - Andrew Derenzy's Brother-In-Law |
| Jennifer Darby | .... Pizza shop patron |
| Chris Goad | .... Detective Hamilton |
| Josh Hamilton | .... Self - Det., Hope Mills NC Police Department |
| Isaiah Hanley | .... Andrew Derenzy |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Mary Miles Kokotek | .... Ms. Hall the 'Bailbond Mom' |
| Eric Lang | .... Ken Lombard |
| Toni Henderson Mayers | .... Elizabeth |
| Julianne Norkus | .... Crime Scene Investigator |
| Jordan Pope | .... Daniel Hall |
| Sean Ramey | .... Detective Reagan |
| George Regan | .... Self - Det., Hope Mills NC Police Department |
| Aimee Smith | .... Self - Andrew Derenzy's Sister |
| Justin Sterner | .... Ian Robinson |
| Billy West | .... Self - District Attorney, Cumberland County North Carolina |
| 8. What She Saw |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Joseph Bellino | .... Self - Det., Prince George's County MD Police Department |
| Chris Caulpetzer | .... Officer |
| Jonathon Church | .... Self - Asst. State's Attorney, Prince George's County Maryla |
| Monika Cope-Ward | .... Self - Social Worker |
| Dana Daniels | .... Self - Tina Towler's Best Friend |
| Jasmine S. Davis | .... Denise Harris |
| Vince Eisenson | .... Det. Bellino |
| Sarah Fawaz | .... Olivia Smith |
| Michael Ganote | .... Bar Patron |
| Frank Harley Jr. | .... Chilly |
| Jay Heselschwerdt | .... Det. Mike Cycienski |
| Kevin Leonard | .... Self - Historian, Laurel Leader |
| William t. McGregor | .... Thurston Yerby |
| Jerry Mortel | .... James |
| Kathleen Scott Paul | .... Tina (reenactment) |
| Arnell Pharr | .... Helpful Witness |
| Scott Rapp | .... Det. Cloyd Steiger |
| Angel R. Reed | .... Angel (surviving victim) |
| Jerome Spencer | .... Self - Asst. State's Attorney, Prince George's County Maryla |
| Jay Towler | .... Self - Ex-Husband of Tina Towler |
| 9. Black Water |
| Mark Breeden | .... Joseph leer |
| Matt Conghlin | .... Self - Journalist & Author |
| Ryan Hammond | .... Detective McMullin |
| Fred Harran | .... Self |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Chris McMullen | .... Self - Det., Bensalem PA Police Department |
| Chris McMullin | .... Self |
| J. Travis Montoya | .... Christian |
| 10. Lights Out |
| Darren Burch | .... Self - Det., Phoenix AZ Police Department (ret.) |
| Brian Scott Gilmore | .... Darren Burch |
| Jill Holder | .... Nurse |
| Christopher Judd | .... Sergeant Markey |
| Joe Kenda | .... Self - Host |
| Adam McGee | .... Mike Urich |
| Caren Pollaccia | .... Self - Det., Oakland Park FL Police Department (ret.) |
| Nancy Valentine | .... Elderly Victim 1 |
| Mike Watkiss | .... Self - Veteran Phoenix Reporter |
|
|
|
